Absorb card fees, or pass them on: surcharge, cash discount, or dual pricing
Every business pays to accept cards. You can build that cost into your prices, or use a program that shifts some of it to customers who pay by card. We set up all four approaches for California businesses and help you pick the one that fits your customers and stays compliant.
What are your options for handling card fees?
The short answer: you can include card processing costs in your listed prices, or you can use a surcharge, a cash discount, or dual pricing so customers who pay by card cover more of the cost. Each one is set up differently, follows different rules, and lands differently with customers.
Before choosing a program, it’s worth checking what you actually pay. Many businesses we review are on tiered or flat-rate pricing and could cut their cost substantially just by moving to transparent interchange-plus. A lower cost might make a program unnecessary. A quick effective-rate check is the place to start.
The four approaches, compared
Fees built into your prices
How it works: your prices already account for card costs, and every customer pays the same price however they pay.
Fits: premium brands, businesses where nearly everyone pays by card, and anyone who wants the simplest customer experience.
Rules: none beyond ordinary pricing. The key is making sure the cost you’re building in is as low as it can be.
Surcharge
How it works: your posted price is the base price, and a percentage is added when a customer pays with a credit card.
Fits: B2B and professional services, and businesses with large tickets where the fee is significant.
Rules: credit cards only, never debit. We set every surcharge at 3% or less on all card brands, and never more than your actual cost of acceptance. It must be disclosed in advance and shown on the receipt.
Cash discount
How it works: your posted price is the card price, and customers who pay with cash get a discount off it.
Fits: quick-service restaurants, auto repair, salons, and convenience retail with a meaningful share of cash customers.
Rules: California law expressly allows discounts for cash. Posted prices must be the card price everywhere, including online menus and delivery apps.
Dual pricing
How it works: you show two prices for each item, a cash price and a card price, like a gas station. The POS charges the right one at checkout.
Fits: businesses that want customers to see both prices up front, and whose POS can display and apply them cleanly.
Rules: both prices must be clearly posted before the customer pays. Like a cash discount, it’s built on the card price being a real listed price, not a fee added at the register.
What does California law allow?
California Civil Code §1748.1 bars retailers from adding a surcharge for paying by credit card, but expressly allows discounts for paying with cash or other methods. In 2018, the Ninth Circuit ruled in Italian Colors Restaurant v. Becerra that the surcharge ban was unconstitutional as applied to the merchants who challenged it. The statute wasn’t repealed, and the Attorney General has said it will generally apply that decision to similarly situated merchants. That’s why surcharging is common in California, and why it has to be set up carefully.
California’s Honest Pricing Law (SB 478) also requires advertised prices to include all mandatory fees. A card surcharge is generally not considered mandatory if customers can avoid it by paying another way. If you accept only credit cards, the fee is mandatory and must be built into your listed prices.
Read more in our guides to credit card surcharging in California and SB 478 and your fees.
Where do programs go wrong?
Visa and Mastercard fine processors for non-compliant programs, and processors pass those fines on to merchants. The most common mistakes we see:
- Renaming a surcharge. A “service fee,” “convenience fee,” or “non-cash adjustment” added at the register is treated as a surcharge, whatever it’s called, and has to follow surcharge rules.
- Surcharging debit cards. It isn’t allowed, even when the debit card is run as credit.
- Charging more than 3% or more than your cost. Visa caps surcharges at 3%, and a surcharge can never exceed your actual cost of acceptance. We apply one rate of 3% or less to every card brand.
- Skipping the notice. The networks require you to notify your processor before you start surcharging. We handle that registration for you.
- Missing or mismatched signs. Disclosures belong at the entrance, at the register, and online before checkout, and your website, menus, and delivery apps have to show consistent prices.
We’re not attorneys, and this isn’t legal advice. For your specific situation, talk with a California business attorney. On the payments side, we set up the terminals, receipts, signage, and processor registration so your program is configured correctly from day one.
Which approach is right for you?
Lower your cost first
Move to interchange-plus and remove junk fees. Sometimes that’s enough.
Look at your customers
How many pay cash, how many use debit, and how sensitive they are to seeing a fee.
Check your POS
Your system has to display and apply the program cleanly in store and online.
Set it up correctly
Registration, terminal settings, signs, and receipt language, all done before your first sale.
For a deeper comparison, read cash discount vs. surcharge and cash discount programs, explained honestly.
Could the rules change?
Possibly. A pending settlement between Visa, Mastercard, and merchants would give businesses more flexibility on surcharging and on which card types they accept. The court granted preliminary approval in June 2026, and final approval is expected in late 2026 or early 2027, with possible appeals after that. We follow it closely and explain the details in card network changes coming in 2027.
Pricing program questions
Both start from the card price. A cash discount posts only the card price and gives cash customers a discount at checkout. Dual pricing posts both prices side by side so customers see the cash price and the card price before they decide how to pay.
No. Card-network rules prohibit surcharging debit and prepaid cards, even when they’re run as credit. A properly set up surcharge program detects debit cards automatically.
Keep it at 3% or less on every card. Visa caps surcharges at 3%, and while Mastercard’s own rules allow up to 4%, surcharge programs apply one rate across all card brands, so 3% is the practical ceiling. California law doesn’t set a percentage of its own. A surcharge also can’t exceed your actual cost of acceptance, so for many businesses the right number is their real effective rate, often below 3%.
Some will notice, especially with a surcharge. Clear signs, consistent prices, and staff who can explain the program in one sentence make the biggest difference. Businesses whose customers are price-sensitive often prefer building fees into prices instead.
No. They shift some of the cost to card customers. Processing still has a cost, and some providers that advertise “free processing” charge high markups on the program itself. We show you the real numbers either way.
Not sure which approach fits?
Send us your latest statement. We’ll show you your true cost of accepting cards and what each option would look like for your business.
